• Products
  • Fetured Items
  • View Cart
  • My Account
  • Customer Service
  • Articles
  • Algae Control Product Comparison Chart

    This chart is intended to be a guideline to assist you in selecting the algae control method that works for you. 
    Every pond is different and results will vary from situation to situation.  No guarantees are implied by the resource listed below.

    Index of Algae
    Control Products
     Green  
    Water1
     Filamentous 
    Algae2
     Algaecide3   Flocculent4  Natural
     Bacteria
    Enzyme5
     Oxidizer6   Pond 
    Dye7
    Safe
    for

     Plants8 
     Safe 
    for
    fish9
     Customer
    Rating
    10
    Accu-Clear Yes     Yes       Yes Yes  
    AlgaeFix Yes Yes Yes         Yes Yes 5 Stars
    Algae-Off   Yes Yes     Yes   Yes Yes  
    Algaway 5.4 Yes Yes Yes         Yes Yes 4.5 Stars
    Barley Straw Yes Yes     Yes     Yes Yes 3 Star Rating
    Barley Extract Yes Yes     Yes     Yes Yes 5 Stars
    Biological Clarifier  
    (dry, liquid, Water Soluble)
    Yes Yes     Yes     Yes Yes  
    Bio-Filter Booster Yes Yes     Yes     Yes Yes  
    Blue Lagoon Yes Yes         Yes Yes Yes 5 Stars
    Clarity Max Yes Yes     Yes     Yes Yes 5 Stars
    EcoFix Yes Yes     Yes     Yes Yes 5 Stars
    Fountec Yes Yes Yes         Yes    
    GreenEx Yes Yes     Yes     Yes Yes  
    Loch Ness Yes Yes         Yes Yes Yes  
    PolyOx Yes Yes       Yes   Yes Yes  
    Microbe Lift PL Yes Yes     Yes     Yes Yes 5 Stars
    Microbe Lift Gel Yes Yes     Yes     Yes Yes  
    Microbe Lift Sludge Away Yes Yes     Yes     Yes Yes  
    Microbe Lift Spring/Summer Yes Yes     Yes     Yes Yes  
    Microbe Lift Autumn Winter Yes Yes     Yes     Yes Yes 5 Stars
    Microbe Lift Oxy Pond Cleaner     Yes Yes     Yes   Yes Yes 5 Stars
    Nitrifier Yes Yes     Yes     Yes Yes  
    Pond Block Yes Yes Yes           Yes  
    PondZyme Plus Yes Yes     Yes     Yes Yes 5 Stars
    Simply Clear Yes     Yes Yes     Yes Yes 5 Stars
    Pond Fizz Water Shade Yes Yes         Yes Yes Yes  
    Pond Fizz Oxy Clear Yes Yes       Yes   Yes Yes  
    Barley Planters Yes Yes     Yes     Yes Yes  
    Microbe Lift Bio-Blue Yes Yes     Yes   Yes Yes Yes  
    Microbe Lift Bio-Black Yes Yes     Yes   Yes Yes Yes  
    Ultraviolet Clarifiers Yes             Yes Yes  

    1Green Water - This refers to the single-cell algae that make water appear green. Green water is often called pea soup water.

    2Filamentous Algae - This refers to many types of multi-cellular algae that form clusters of algae that can be physically handled.
    Common terms include; string algae, blanketweed, hair algae. [Back to Top]

    3Algaecide - These products are registered with the EPA as true algaecides. These products should directly kill algae within the pond.

    4Flocculent - A flocculent causes suspended organic material in the pond to clump up and sink. This does not eliminate them from the water,
    but should provide good, temporary results. It can also allow your mechanical filter to better trap the larger particles.

    5Natural Bacteria/Enzyme - These products are all-natural items formulated from living bacteria and/or enzymes. These do not have a direct
    control of algae. They will improve the conditions within the pond to help reduce algae growth. [Back to Top]

    6Oxidizer - These products will chemically break down organics in the water reducing sludge and algae.

    7Pond Dye - The dyes can be used for simply the decorative effect, but they also limit the amount of sunlight penetrating the water reducing
    algae growth.

    8Safe for Plants - These products should not harm plant life when used as directed. [Back to Top]

    9Safe for Fish - These products should not harm fish when used as directed.

    10Customer Rating - Average rating from our customers who have written reviews of the product. Not all products have been customer
    reviewed.

    [Back to Top]